Legal Action
Bull Bitcoin's legal action before the Conseil d'État
The challenge filed against the French DAC8 transposition decree and why it matters.
Updated
On 24 February 2026, Bull Bitcoin filed a summary petition (requête sommaire) before the French Conseil d’État against Decree No. 2025-1276 of 19 December 2025, the main French transposition measure for DAC8.
This action is only a beginning. It is part of a broader strategy to suspend, delay, annul or amend the harmful effects of DAC8 and CARF by every legitimate legal means available. It matters beyond France, because DAC8 is part of a broader global architecture for crypto tax reporting.
Short answer
On 24 February 2026, Bull Bitcoin filed a summary petition (requête sommaire) before the Conseil d’État to annul Decree No. 2025-1276 of 19 December 2025, the main French transposition measure for DAC8. It is the first step of a broader strategy to suspend, delay, annul or amend the harmful effects of DAC8 and CARF by every legitimate means.
The supplementary brief, filed on 22 May 2026, develops the legal grounds. The appeal requests the Conseil d’État to refer the matter to the Court of Justice of the European Union regarding the validity of the directive.
Key facts
| Question | Answer |
|---|---|
| Petition filed | Summary petition (requête sommaire), 24 February 2026 |
| Court | Conseil d’État (France) |
| Challenged text | Decree No. 2025-1276 of 19 December 2025 |
| EU framework | DAC8 (and CARF at the global level) |
| Claimant | Bull Bitcoin |
| First in Europe | Bull Bitcoin’s petition is the first legal action against DAC8 in Europe; Austria followed in October 2026 |
| Immediate goal | Annulment of the challenged decree |
| Supplementary brief | Filed on 22 May 2026 |
| Timeline | Proceedings ongoing; referral to the Court of Justice of the EU requested |
| Interim suspension | Rejected on 14 September 2026, without examining the legality of the decree |
| Overall strategy | Suspend, delay, annul or amend the effects of DAC8 and CARF |
The main legal grounds
The reference file identifies three lines of argument:
- Over-transposition and abuse of power (excès de pouvoir) : the decree would extend the obligations beyond the necessary scope.
- Procedural irregularity : the procedure by which the decree was adopted is contested.
- Disproportionate infringement of fundamental rights : the automated collection of exhaustive financial data infringes privacy and data protection.
Why the action is strategic
The litigation is not only about a technical text. It seeks recognition that the French transposition of DAC8 cannot ignore the specific nature of crypto-assets, the transparency of public blockchains and the physical risk borne by holders and their relatives.
A victory would create a useful precedent for other member states and for the discussions around CARF. The stakes go beyond France, because DAC8 is part of a broader global architecture for crypto tax reporting.
Procedure timeline
The summary petition opens the litigation. The supplementary brief, filed on 22 May 2026, develops the legal grounds. The appeal requests the Conseil d’État to refer the matter to the Court of Justice of the European Union regarding the validity of the directive.
What the action seeks
The immediate goal is the annulment of the challenged French decree. The broader goal is to establish a precedent on the proportionality of mechanisms for the automatic, mass exchange of crypto data.
Bull Bitcoin wants to open an institutional dialogue on an alternative compatible with taxation, security and fundamental rights.
The movement spreads
Bull Bitcoin’s petition was the first legal action against DAC8 in Europe. In October 2026, the Vienna-based association Bitcoin Austria filed its own challenge in Austria, with lawyer Oliver Völkel (CERHA HEMPEL), and presents the dac8.com campaign as the inspiration for its own. Every transposition of DAC8 can be challenged before national courts: see the European front against DAC8.